When it comes to training your dog and correcting undesirable behaviors, shock collars can be a very useful tool for you. However, this is a controversial gadget since it delivers some form of electricity in our pets.
Despite this, shock collars in the hands of a skilled dog handler can turn into an invaluable tool. And just like any other tool, there are pros and cons to using it. As such, we’ve done all the research for you to provide you with enough knowledge to help you decide on which is the best shock collar that’ll fit your pet’s needs.
The Best Dog Shock Collars
If you’re in a hurry, here’s a summary of the best dog shock collars:
- Best overall – DOG CARE Dog Training Collar
- Best shock collars on a budget – TBI Pro Dog Shock Training Collar
- Best shock collars for big breeds – SportDOG FieldTrainer SD-425
- Best shock collars for small dogs – Petrainer Dog Collar
- Best value – Educator E-Collar Remote Dog Training Collar
Compared to other dog shock collars, the Educator training collar simply delivers a tapping sensation. It’s similar to vibration and provides an adjustable simulation so you can easily customize it depending on your dog’s size and weight.
This is one of the best selling shock collars in the market today. Mostly because of how comfortable it is and how it provides your pet with a clean simulation compared to the neck jerking motions that other training collars offer. But that’s not all, this training collar is also waterproof and very durable so you can be confident that it will last a very long time.
- Waterproof receiver and remote control
- Easy to hold transmitter
- Available in 1/2 mile range or 3/4 mile range
- User-selectable stimulation levels from 1 to 100
- Rechargeable batteries with dual charger
- Provides light tapping sensation instead of a jolt
- Comfortable for the dog
- Adjustable stimulation levels
- Outstanding range
- You might need to charge the battery every day
- Need some time to getting used to
The DOG CARE Dog Training Collar is perfect if you have several dogs. You can use one remote for up to nine collars. With a security keypad lock in place, it’s easier to prevent any accidental shocks or misfires. This collar has up to 99 static shock levels so you can adjust easily and find the best setting for your dog.
- Adjustable collar
- Offers 99 different levels of static shock
- Provides 3 extremely efficient and safe training mode
- Security keypad lock
- Supports a maximum of 9 dogs training with only 1 remote transmitter
- Up to 330 yards remote range
- Prevent accidental shocks with the security keypad feature
- Smooth adjustable settings
- Choose from three training settings
- Tricky to use on dogs with thick fur
- May not be effective on small dogs
- Contact on the dog’s skin may not be consistently applied
The Petrainer dog collar features three training modes for you to choose from including static stimulation & vibration and standard tone mode. The system offers a standard beep and 100 levels of vibrate and shock stimulation for you to choose from.
The receiver is very durable especially since it’s waterproof while its transmitter is protected from electrical issues and overheating. Plus, its remote range can go up to 330 yards.
- 3 modes – beep mode, vibration mode, and shock mode
- 100 levels of static shock and vibration, 1 level of standard tone
- 330-yard remote range
- Adjustable collar (6 to 25 inches)
- Automatic standby and memory function to help you save power
- Rechargeable batteries
- Simple and easy to use design
- Adjustable stimulation
- Receiver and transmitter can be charged at the same time
- There’s no way to lock the buttons on the remote so be careful on putting it on your pocket or you might accidentally shock your pup
If you have big dogs, the SportDOG FieldTrainer SD-425 is perfect for you. However, it’s a bit expensive than most shock collars but it’s worth every penny. It’s mainly designed for hunters and sporting purposes with its 500-yard remote range and capability of pairing one remote to 3 collars. It’s also waterproof up to 25 feet.
Unlike other dog training collars, the SportDOG FieldTrainder SD-425 features momentary and continuous static simulation options. The collar also comes with rechargeable batteries that can go from 50 to 70 hours.
- Low battery indicator
- Waterproof up to 25 feet
- 500-yard remote range
- 7 levels of static stimulation which includes burst or continuous modes
- Battery can last from 50 to 70 hours
- Great for large breeds
- Wide range of transmission
- Customizable settings and levels
- Offers momentary and continuous stimulation
- One remote can connect to 3 collars
- Comes with a training DVD
- Some users reported difficulty in using the collar with small dogs
Compared to other dog training collars, the Patpet Dog Training Collar is an excellent tool for the blind to train their dogs. With this in mind, this dog collar is extremely user-friendly.
It has a 1000 yard range so if you’re planning on going to the park or any wide space, this is perfect for you. One remote can control up to 2 dog collars.
For best results, make sure to reposition the collar every 1 to 2 hours and avoid leaving the collar for more than 12 hours per day.
- Blind operation design
- 3 training modes – beep, vibration, and shock
- Fits all dogs from 9 lbs and larger
- Can control up to 2 collar receivers
- IPX7 Waterproof
- 1000 yards remote range
- Rechargeable batteries
- Remote control battery status is shown on the LED display
- Easy to use
- Collar receiver is 100% waterproof
- Wide remote range
- Comes with a multi-functional Lanyard
- Battery may not last more than few hours
Do you have stubborn pets? Start training your dogs with the TBI Pro Dog Shock Training Collar. It’s the best shock collar in terms of providing versatile options and affordability. Not only that but a single 2-3 hour charge can last your battery up to 15-20 days! And it’s waterproof, too!
What’s more it has a powerful processor with a 2000 feet remote range. You can also choose from 3 training modes of signal and vibration with 100 adjustable levels so you can adjust it to fit your pets needs.
Before using it, make sure the collar is adjusted correctly. Depending on the contact of the collar to your dog’s skin, you might find different tolerance levels. You can try marking the collar where you tested it with success and keep it there whenever you put it on your pup. This will help you have consistent results.
- Provides 2000 feet remote range
- Offers 3 training modes
- Adjustable signal and vibration levels
- Waterproof collar
- Rechargeable battery with up to 15-20 days of active use
- Easy to use
- Longer battery life than most dog training collars
- Assures control in longer distances
- Provides 3 training modes
- If your dog has long hair, you might need to trim the hair so that the contact points are consistent
- Some users have reported that while the collar is waterproof, the water may increase the shock intensity when you use it
With 4 training modes, the PetSpy Premium training collar is great for both first-time dog parents and expert trainers. It has 8 adjustable levels for dogs so you can easily adjust depending on your pet’s size and sensitivity.
It’s easy to use with its blind operation design. You don’t need to keep looking at the remote. Plus, it has a 1100 yards remote range!
This dog collar is waterproof and works great for all breeds from 10 to 140 lbs.
- Waterproof and rechargeable receiver with remote activation
- 4 training modes with 8 adjustable levels
- 1100 yards remote range
- Blind operation design
- Includes a dog training e-book
- Contact points are made of conductive rubber to prevent skin irritation
- Dual quick charge
- May need longer prongs for dogs with thick hair
How Does A Shock Collar Work
Before you can use a shock collar on your dog, it’s important to learn how it works. This way, you can use it to its full extent and avoid accidentally shocking your dog.
Just like its name, shock collars work by delivering an electric stimulus to your dog’s body. This is to startle your dog or stop your pup from doing something. Each shock collar is different. Some deliver two, three, or all of these stimuli – auditory, vibration, visual, or static electricity. The stimulus you need will depend on your dog. Several dog owners have found that vibration works while others have found success with auditory.
The stimulus can work as long as your dog is wearing his collar. But to make sure that it’s effective, check that the collar’s prongs are in full contact with your dog’s skin.
To activate the shock collar, you’ll need to meet a certain preset threshold. There are shock collars that allow you to register your dog’s bark so whenever your pet barks, it will activate.
For most training collars, you’ll find that each comes in a set – the collar and the remote. You can use the remote to activate the collar. According to experts, the best way to use a shock collar is to start with visual, auditory, or vibration mode. If these are not effective in correcting your dog’s behavior or stopping your dog from whatever it’s doing, then you can use the static training mode.
Keep in mind that shock collars should not be used as punishment but more of a deterrent to unsafe or negative behavior. The theory behind shock collars is that your dog will associate the unwanted behavior with the slightly uncomfortable stimulus and will stop doing whatever they’re doing up until they will no longer require any reminder.
Types of Shock Collars
Currently, you will find three types of shock collars in the market:
Anti-bark collars, just like its name, are used to control your dog’s barking. Dogs bark naturally. It’s in their genes. However, if your dog barks at almost everything and at inappropriate times, a shock collar can be used to teach him the right behavior without all the shouting.
However, the anti-bark collar is not activated by any remote but by a sensor inside it. When your dog barks, it activates the collar. An impulse will then be delivered to your dog. We recommend getting collars that have feature different modes such as vibration, beep or shock.
Do note that the anti-bark collar is not perfect and can sometimes be activated by other loud noise such as cars, kids yelling, thunderstorm or other dogs barking. This will result to your pup associating this sounds to a negative reaction and will mostly lead to behavioral or psychological issues. Both of which are harder to fix.
With these in mind, only buy an anti-bark collar as a last resort.
Invisible Fence Collars
Invisible fence collars are much like the anti-bark collars. The only difference is that invisible fence collars activate when they receive signals from perimeter devices. The most popular modes include beep, shock and vibration.
Perimeter devices are wireless devices or wires you place around to confine a certain area. Whenever your dog trespasses these devices, the shock collar will activate. These are great for keeping your dogs within your camping area or your backyard.
As for the price, invisible fence collars can be a bit expensive compared to other systems.
Training collars, also known as e-collars or remote collars are designed like traditional collars but with a receiver device that receives signals from a remote control. Most training collars today have three modes – beep, static, and vibration. If you’re planning on buying a training collar, make sure it has all these three.
The other part of a training collar is the remote control which sends the signals to the receiver. Some remotes offer one button which allows you to switch between each function. If you’re not careful, you might accidentally shock your dog. These types are a bit of a hassle to handle since you still have to switch between modes.
The best training collars would be ones with a button for each mode. Blind coded ones are even better so you know what buttons you’re pressing without looking at the remote.
Compared to anti-bark collars and invisible fence collars, training collars are used to teach dog obedience or correct aggressive behavior in wide open spaces.
Here’s a video on how to use an electric collar to train a dog to come when called.
What You Should Know Before Buying A Shock Collar For Your Dog
So what should you know before buying a shock collar an what things should you consider before buying one?
Things To Consider Before Buying A Shock Collar
Choose a shock collar with multiple modes especially when you don’t know what stimulus your dog will respond to. Start with the low settings using the beeps first then gradually moving to vibrations. If nothing works, then you can use the shocks but make sure the intensity isn’t too strong or you might do more harm than good.
If you have a big yard or love bringing your dog to parks, then you need a larger remote range area. Check the shock collar’s remote range if you’re planning on using the shock collar for behavior training in a large area. Most come with a range of around 1000 feet and can extend up to 500 yards or more.
Remotes are another thing that you should consider. A better one would have several buttons for each mode and if possible have a lock in place so you don’t accidentally shock your dog when the remote is in your pocket.
Consider buying a shock collar that’s weatherproofed. This is a handy feature if your dog loves swimming or playing in puddles.
Levels of Stimulation
Always check your shock collar’s level of stimulation. One can have up to 100 levels and can help immensely in training your dog.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do shock collars really hurt dogs?
If you’re using the electric stimulation on your dog, there’s no way to actually measure whether the electricity will hurt your dog. However, there aren’t any objective evidence that shows it doesn’t.
Dog shock collar manufacturers have duly acknowledged that electricity, no matter how small, can cause injury or tissue inflammation around the area where the collar’s prongs are in contact with skin. This instance usually happens when the collar is worn for an extended amount of time or has been frequently used.
The thing is, it’s hard to find any inflammation or injury on your dog if you’re using electric stimulation on your dog since the affected tissues are usually deep under the skin. You might not see it but the damage can be already forming in underlying tissues or deep in the skin.
Because of this, a lot of people don’t recommend using shock collars and only advise that the static correction should only be used as a last resort. It’s best to use the beep and vibration functions first. Should you ever use the electric stimulation, it’s recommended you always use the lowest setting.
Is it safe to use shock collars?
Yes and No.
No. Shock collars that only provide electric stimulus are never safe. There’s also nothing “humane” about passing electricity onto your dog’s body.
And yes, shock collars are safe if you use the beep, audio, tone or vibration modes. No tissue injuries occur within these modes.
All in all, shock correction isn’t the best way to train your dogs. Even manufacturers indirectly admit it. If not, they would have only created shock-only collars.
However, it doesn’t mean that these are not useful. There are dogs that don’t respond to any traditional training or strategies.In these cases, shock collars might just be the only solution.
How long can you leave a bark collar on a dog?
Don’t leave the shock collar on at all times. Only use it when training your dog and not control him. Allow him the opportunity to bark once in a while. In addition to training, use the collar for only around 1 to 2 hours.
Some owners have reportedly found success in leaving the collar on for a few more hours but turned off.